It may not be a 100% complete list but we try to be thorough. We did not attempt any repairs.
These are all numbered so you can match the controller with the description of problems found. Controller 1 Left stick drifts up. Controller 3 Missing rubber on the trigger stops, "x" is hard to activate.
Controller 4 Left trigger is sticking, RB not working, controller is sticky, missing rubber on trigger stops. Controller 5 Won't sync, Left stick is broken. Each comes with semi soft case, 2 of 6 thumbsticks, no charge base, 0 of 4 paddles, 1 of 2 d-pads, no charge cable and no adjustment tool.